Overview
I have a finical accounting assignment, and I have made most of it, while still require some modification and review if you could review it and modify, I can share with you my answers and the requirements.
we have put our assignment in Chat GPT and show us the missing while I don't want to depend on it and this what make me share it with you to review and modify any of the writing ppt or excel based on the doctor requirements and references.
The attached picture show how we splitted it:
Green part is for SARA and yellow part is for Areej and the purple part is for Razan
additionally we have at the begging select 5 companies while I didn't find their info so I chose the one in the assignment if you have an access into a one of the reference the doctor mentioned and have the info you may change the company or leave it as they are if they are good
Chat GPT review: Review Summary: Each Member’s Part
Sarah – Comparable Multiples (P/S & P/E)
✅ Strengths:
Clearly selected and justified 5 relevant companies
Used actual data from Yahoo Finance & Gurufocus
Provided both P/E and P/S valuations with formulas
🛠 Improvements Needed:
Use a consistent average P/E and P/S ratio in the narrative (you said P/E = 16.36, but referenced 18 earlier)
Explain a bit more why each company was selected individually (just 1 line per company)
Visual support (charts/tables) would strengthen the argument
Razan – Acquisition Premium + PEG + Final Recommendation
✅ Strengths:
Correct calculation of acquisition premium
Strong theoretical context on goodwill, private firm attractiveness, etc.
Clear PEG ratio logic and comparison to industry
🛠 Improvements Needed:
The DCF value listed under PEG ($4.5M) is incorrect — use Areej’s $34.4M
The PEG ratio formula (45.8 ÷ 4.5) lacks clarity. 4.5 isn’t ABM’s growth rate — needs correction.
You should define your chosen final value range more clearly.
Areej – DCF Model
✅ Strengths:
Professional explanation of assumptions (growth rates, cost structure, capex, working capital)
Calculated DCF value and terminal value correctly
Good reference to industry peers and benchmark justification
🛠 Improvements Needed:
Include a summary table of FCFs per year to reinforce clarity
State clearly that “Net Debt = $0” and show how it affects Equity Value
Add brief justification for terminal growth rate (2%)
Requirements: review only