Overview
The critique should have two parts. The first part should focus on the objective critique of the article, listing your concerns and the reasons for your concerns. This should focus on issues such as, but not limited to, the relevance and objectives of the research, assumptions made, modeling/experimental techniques used, solutions developed, statistical tests used, findings presented, and conclusions made. The second part should focus on how you propose to improve the paper or extend the results.
It is expected that this paper will be one of the papers reviewed for the synthesis paper and that the critique of it will sharpen your critique of the technical literature and motivate you toward proposing new research.
Use 12-point font, double-spacing, and one-inch margins in the write-up.