CSR reality check discussion

CH3 | Discussion

Discussion Option B: CSR Reality Check (Artifact + Peer Video Replies)

In this discussion, you’ll evaluate a real organization’s CSR choices using Chapter 3 frameworks. You’ll analyze actions through Carroll’s CSR Pyramid and the Triple Bottom Line, then connect those actions to pressures from the task and general environments. You’ll create a simple artifact that helps you argue whether the company’s CSR efforts are balanced—or missing something important.

Instructions

• Initial post format: Written post + attached artifact (required)
• Artifact options (choose 1):
  • A one-page CSR Scorecard (table or infographic)
  • A 2×2 graphic that compares “People/Planet/Profit” strengths and gaps
  • A 1-slide CSR Pyramid with company examples placed at each level
• Peer response format: Video (preferred, 60–90 seconds) or audio

Required evidence (to keep your post course-grounded):

• Reference at least three Chapter 3 concepts by name (CSR Pyramid levels, Triple Bottom Line, stakeholders, task environment, general environment, ethical responsibilities, etc.).
• Use one specific reference from the textbook or lecture shorts to support your evaluation.
• Use a real organization (current or recent examples) and include enough detail that your classmates can understand the context.

Initial Post Prompts (Answer all)

1. Choose a company and describe the CSR actions:
   Pick a company you’re familiar with (employer, brand you use, local business, or a well-known organization).
   • List two CSR-related actions the company has taken (or claims to take).
   • Identify the key stakeholders most affected (customers, employees, community, owners, regulators, suppliers).
2. Analyze (CSR Pyramid + Triple Bottom Line):
   Place your examples into:
   • Carroll’s CSR Pyramid (which level(s) do your examples represent, and why?)
   • Triple Bottom Line (which dimension—people/planet/profit—is strongest, and which is weakest?)
3. Evaluate (What’s missing?):
   Make a judgment call: Is this company’s CSR approach balanced, mostly PR, or strong but incomplete?
   • Defend your evaluation using at least one textbook/lecture concept.
   • Identify one improvement the company should make and explain which CSR level or TBL dimension it strengthens.
4. Create (Artifact requirement):
   Create and attach your chosen artifact (scorecard, 2×2, or pyramid slide). Your artifact must clearly show:
   • Where your company’s examples fit (CSR Pyramid and/or TBL)
   • At least one “gap” or missing area
   • Your recommended improvement

Peer Responses

• Respond to: 2 classmates
• Format: Video (60–90 seconds) or audio
• Required move: In your video, reference your peer’s artifact (point to a section, quote one label, or name one example they placed).

Peer Response Prompts (choose 1–2 to address):

• Consider your peer’s artifact: Where did they place an example in the CSR Pyramid or TBL that you agree with? Where would you place it differently, and why (use a Chapter 3 definition)?
• Consider your peer’s evaluation: Do you agree their company is balanced/PR/incomplete? Identify one piece of missing evidence or one stakeholder they underweighted, using course concepts.
• Consider your peer’s improvement idea: Suggest one alternative improvement that targets a different CSR level or TBL dimension, and explain why it may be more impactful.

How to Record Your Video

Option A: Record directly in Canvas (Rich Content Editor)

1. Open the discussion and click Reply.
2. In the editor toolbar, select Record/Upload Media (often shown as a play/film icon).
3. Choose Record Media.
4. Select your microphone/camera, record, then click Save.
5. Post your reply.

Tip: If your browser blocks your camera/mic, allow permissions and refresh the page.

Option B: Record with Panopto and embed/link

1. Open Panopto from the course navigation menu.
2. Create a new recording using Panopto Capture (or the browser recorder, if available).
3. Save the recording to the course folder.
4. Copy the share link (or embed option) and paste it into your discussion reply.

Accessibility reminder: If possible, use captions (Panopto) or add a short text summary under your video (3–5 bullets).