Instructions
Select THREE SETS out of four sets of readings. For each “Reading 1” under each set, state the conclusion and identify at least three premises or reasons that support the conclusion. Provide a brief account of the evidence or reason for each premise. For each “Reading 2” under each set, identify at least two relevant objections that it raises. 10 points for each set. Your final exam grade is out of 30 points (not out of 40 points). The sets below are the same ones you will see as the actual questions for the final exam. I suggest that you respond to them first before you click on the questions for the final exam. You can just paste your responses later, in order for you not to go over the time limit.
SET #1: Chapter Two - "America First"
Reading 1: Daniel Bonevac, "America First" (pp. 123 - 131)
Reading 2: Gillian Brock, "Reply to Bonevac" (pp. 145 - 146)
SET #2: Chapter Two - “America First”
Reading 1: Gillian Brock, “Defending the Cosmopolitan Outlook” (pp. 133 – 140)
Reading 2: Daniel Bonevac, “Reply to Brock” (pp. 142 – 144)
SET #3: Chapter Four – “Immigration”
Reading 1: Peter Jaworski, “Markets without Labor Limits: Crimes, Welfare, Jobs, and Culture” (pp. 183 – 190)
Reading 2: Hrishikesh Joshi, “Reply to Jaworski” (pp. 202 – 203)
SET #4: Chapter Four – “Immigration”
Reading 1: Hrishikesh Joshi, “For (Some) Immigration Restrictions” (pp. 191 – 198)
Reading 2: Peter Jaworski, “Reply to Joshi” (pp. 199 – 201)